These statements and their consequences are symptoms of a growing trend in Western politics: the re-emergence of racial views of human nature that have been largely in hiding for the past 70 years. Narratives about the innate intellectual inferiority of black or brown people compared with white people—which can still be found in academic journals today—are fuelling far-right propaganda in some of the world’s largest democracies. Such claims underpin misinformation strategies on social media and bolster political movements.

These narratives are sometimes euphemistically referred to as “race science” or more recently “race realism.” But, as we argue, they are not actually scientific. One member of this community, Nathan Cofnas, recently attracted public attention by accusing the late Jason Arday of plagiarism.

What got less attention was that Cofnas has links to a network of people who make supposedly scientific claims about the innate intelligence, criminality, or sexuality of different racial groups. Some within this network are affiliated with universities, giving their work the mask of legitimacy.

This group produces work that has the appearance of science, but which is methodologically deeply flawed and fails to engage with rigorous scientific research. Yet they regularly succeed in publishing this work in (a handful of) mainstream academic journals.

…

As one of us recently outlined in a peer-reviewed paper, race scientists are largely silent on the social brain hypothesis—the view that humans evolved remarkable intellectual abilities to manage social issues. In every group, there is strong social competition around resources, mating, and status. These are the things humans spend the most time navigating—the complexities of our rich social lives.

Not one of the prominent mainstream views on the evolution of human intelligence concludes there are innate cognitive differences between racial groups. Factors that have been put forward range from our cooperative child rearing to our heavy reliance on culture and learning. These all involve our social relationships, and all have received equal lack of attention from race scientists.

Mainstream opinion in the evolutionary behavioral sciences is that cognitively, all human groups are the same, though of course individuals within groups differ. Our amazing behavioral diversity stems from our species’ ability to adapt flexibly to our environment. This is especially because of our reliance on culture and social learning—not because we have evolved different psychologies to suit different environments.

  • JasSmith@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    10 hours ago

    A lot of different concepts got lumped into this article and it does a disservice to the discussion.

    IQ tests have been administered across the world for decades, and general intelligence (g) is one of the most extensively researched constructs in psychology. A 2023 systematic review of 57 cross-cultural studies found strong evidence that the underlying structure of cognitive ability generalises across cultures. The authors also argue that IQ tests don’t capture creativity or social intelligence. Of course they don’t. IQ is an imperfect measure of g, not a measure of every conceivable human ability. That doesn’t invalidate what it actually measures.

    More importantly, IQ’s predictive validity is extraordinarily well established. A meta-analysis of longitudinal research found correlations of 0.56 with educational attainment, 0.43 with occupational status and 0.20 with income. These are significant, repeatedly demonstrated relationships, particularly for education and occupation. The evidence that IQ predicts important life outcomes is conclusive, even if it doesn’t outperform every other predictor in every circumstance. Parental socioeconomic background and academic achievement can also be similarly predictive. None of this changes the fact that intelligence testing has substantial scientific and practical validity.

    The worst issue with the article is the discussion re genetics. The Flynn effect demonstrates that environmental changes can substantially affect average IQ scores. It does not disprove the considerable genetic contribution to individual differences in intelligence. This is something research explicitly examining this apparent paradox has established. Nor does it settle the causes of differences between populations. Equally, problems with a particular national IQ database cannot justify dismissing the broader field of psychometrics.

    I think the fact that genetics can make populations smarter or dumber makes people really uncomfortable, and so they reject clear scientific evidence. That’s not a healthy response. Instead we should accept that different populations are different, and that’s okay. We should promote the idea that we are all innately valuable, irrespective of our intelligence. Denying the research implies that people are less valuable if they are less intelligent, and given the evidence, does a major disservice to the discussion.

    • Hetare King@piefed.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      5 hours ago

      It does not disprove the considerable genetic contribution to individual differences in intelligence. This is something research explicitly examining this apparent paradox has established.

      Have they actually established this or have they just found correlations between genetics and IQ? Because they would have to account for some very significant confounding factors. Like, if you live in, say, Cameroon (and therefore very likely to be genetically similar to other people living in Cameroon), you’re much more likely to be a sustenance farmer than someone who lives in Germany, who is more likely to be an office worker. So in their daily lives, the Cameroonian and the German here would use their brains in very different ways, which affects what neural pathways get strengthened the most, with the German’s cognitive work being the more similar to the kind of abstract logic puzzles you would find in an IQ test.

      So to establish a link between genetics and IQ, they would have to completely eradicate the influence of those factors from their data. They can’t just look at immigrants either, because then they would have to account for the effects of racism and other disadvantages immigrants and minorities in general face.

      • JasSmith@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        3 hours ago

        I think your Cameroon/Germany example identifies a possible environmental explanation but it doesn’t establish that explanation as the cause. You’re also setting an impossible standard by insisting that researchers must completely eliminate every environmental confound before identifying genetic effects. If that were the standard, we would throw out 99% of research from sociology and psychology.

        The gold standard for this research is twin studies. They take two twins, separated at birth, and conduct longitudinal studies. This research (thousands of studies over decades spanning 100+ countries) shows IQ to be highly heritable. Again, this does NOT mean genetics are the only factor. There are many. It is the most correlated factor in most studies.

        This is a personal topic of interest of mine so if you’re genuinely interested I have an extensive collection of studies I can cite. As above, it is the most well research phenomenon in all of psychology and sociology.

  • DemonGroover@lemmus.org
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    16
    ·
    19 hours ago

    From my personal experience working closely with various African and Middle Eastern people, culture has a definite bearing on how people think but race has zero bearing on actual intelligence.

  • roofuskit@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    19 hours ago

    You can use genetics to divide humans in to as many or as few races as you please. Races are bunk.

  • yermaw@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    12 hours ago

    I always assumed there was something to it. It makes sense, like dog breeds.

    I haven’t looked into it at all though, and know in my soul that there’s way more damage to be done from bolstering racism than advantages to gain from studying it.

    • Hetare King@piefed.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      7 hours ago

      While there are languages where “breed” and “race” are the same word, they’re not really good analogies for each other. Unlike dog breeds, races aren’t a very meaningful way of dividing up humanity.

      And even those dog breeds aren’t all that different from each other. They look very different, because with dogs, even small genetic changes can have a large effect on their appearance, but the personality traits we associate with breeds have more to do with our perception and who their owners are than any innate quality of a breed. This is a generalisation, of course, but the kind of person who would adopt a friendly-looking Labrador is likely to be different kind of person and have different expectations of the dog than someone who would adopt a mean-looking Pitbull. And this will reflect in their training of the dog.

      That’s not to say there aren’t any differences in temperament because of genetics, and especially the basal breeds are going to be most different from each other, but it’s been greatly overstated by kennel clubs.

      • Anon7394@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        5 hours ago

        It is not overstated. A herding dog will herd, a hunting dog will hunt, a sledding dog will want to pull a sled.

        Small genetic differences having a large effect is not limited to dogs, it applies to all living things, including plants. And humans. We aren’t special.

        • Hetare King@piefed.social
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          2 hours ago

          Uh, what? A Border Collie is not going to herd until it’s been trained to herd. A Husky isn’t going to be eager to get into the harness the first time it ever encounters a sled. As for hunting, I mean, dogs are carnivores. And even then, they still have to be trained to not eat the prey.

          Yes, we’ve bred dogs for specific tasks, which has led to a large variety of dog breeds with bodies optimised for those tasks, but that doesn’t mean they’re somehow innately capable of those tasks. Are there dog breeds that are somewhat more or less inclined towards, for example, aggressive behaviour than other, because that was useful for the task they were bred for? Sure. But it’s not nearly to the extent of the associations we have with specific dog breeds.

          And that’s with thousands of years of hyperfocussed breeding. Human reproduction has far less intentionality.

  • iPhoenix@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    19 hours ago

    In terms of skin color, yes, this is bollocks. In terms of culture and scietal or cultural behavior - yes, there are ones that are doing it just better, those that are worse and those that should’ve never been started.