i use mastodon with the same username of lemmy
but its great for me
what is your experience
No, I don’t get the attraction to that medium format just like I don’t understand X, Bluesky, etc. It’s a soapbox format.
Yep. A million preachers in empty churches. I want to actually converse with people
People talk to each other all the time on Mastodon. The posts have commentors that interact with each other and the poster.
Here’s a current random trending post from Viss, who is a cybersecurtiy engineer:
https://mastodon.social/@Viss/117633193893594420
Notice he posted about something he cared about, and is talking to several people about it. This is the common experience there. Its no different than Lemmy/Reddit/etc having an OP post an article, then talking about it with people in the comments.
The only shift is that you follow people or hashtags, not communities. You can tune this pretty well to reflect your interests, just like on Lemmy.
Except the comments aren’t nested in the same way at the top level, a response is just “on your timeline, as a reply”, and most clients don’t allow sorting by likes, which would be the same as upvotes on something like lemmy.
So there’s conversation, but it’s certainly not
no differentthan something like lemmySure, but thats a formatting issue, certainty not “a million preachers in empty churches.” The medium itself matters, but there is a message there that isnt one way or as inherently vapid as its been portrayed.
Not enjoying the chronological structure is plenty of reason not to engage with it, but I find the common argument that “it has no valuable content because its users are just being egotistical” to be a pretty empty critique.
I think this is where a lot of friction comes in with social media and ends up as an under-discussed point, in that not everyone is using the same social media platforms in the same way.
Some people are trying to have conversations, some people are trying to tap into a stream of events, some people are trying to market, and some people like myself are shitposting into the void as an assertion that we’re alive. And we’re all trying to do it on the same platform while shouting past eachother.
I am much more likely to converse with people on mastodon. Here, it is a stream of isolated responses to one-off comments that may or may not be the same person; on masto, you’re talking to someone specific, instead of engaging with isolated comments. We talk about topics in relation to posts and communities; on mastodon we talk about things in relation to the human who is posting them.
Yeah same boat. I never had a Twitter so I never really got used to Bluesky. Mastodon seems too similar of a format for my taste.
I joined a masto instance and still support it financially (because fuck Elon ) but I rarely go there and when I do it’s usually just to do exactly what you said: post soapbox style
Discussion platforms like Lemmy/PieFed are IMO much more… social
No, I don’t like the Twitter format.
Same
No, never got the appeal of micro blogging.
No, cause I don’t know enough people I would want to follow over there and have enough other content to keep me occupied.
FWIW, you can just follow a few hashtags that interest you (like #cats, #yourhometown, #politics, #favoriteauthor, #scifi or whatever) and it will likely generate quite a bit of feed content until you start finding out who you like enough to follow them directly.
In my experience microblogging is not interesting. Mastodon has the exact same niches as Lemmy but way more annoying: science, annoying liberals, and linux.
My favorite example of this is a liberal user was criticizing past protests using the term anarchist. I pointed out their use of the term is incorrect and they are misrepresenting the protests. They then reply how dare I talk down to a black woman…
how could I even know they’re black or a woman and does this fact somehow protect them from being wrong? Classic American liberal mentality. Victimhood mentality.
I don’t use Mastodon or Bluesky. I never liked the Twitter format or way of how it is ever managed. I saw Twitter as an example of how saturated social media is in general when it’s just a freaking comment box with a stupid character limit.
The only thing less interesting to me than twitter is a twitter clone
I don’t have anything against Mastodon. But I don’t use it for the same reason I never used Twitter. I don’t find microblogging sites useful.
Edit: I wrote this before reading the comments and I’m glad to see people still wanting to go back to the forum style of communication.
I am chronically online and I literally never used Twitter except for porn sometimes after Tumblr was ruined by Christians. I don’t need to hear everyone’s shower thoughts throughout the day.
Never bothered with mastadon.
Microblogging is kind of about following a person, and I’m normally less interested in a person than a topic (Reddit-style).
I made very limited, no-account use of Twitter.
There are a few things that I have found Twitter (back before it was login-required) to be good at. Lots of users, so lots of content, and hashtags and retweets were better than the Reddit approach at letting letting temporary, ad hoc communities quickly form for short term events, like natural disaster coverage. Some random person posts cell phone video footage from an incident, other people find it and retweet with hashtags, just works well to tie together relevant information wirhin minutes or hours or an event without the slower Reddit-style community-building approach.
Mastodon doesn’t have the scale of Twitter, so never really drew me in, given that I was never really rabid about the microblog format in the first place.
I also do not like the Twitter format, but I have a Mastodon account just in case. I mostly just use it to log into some services and to repost stuff. My activity is as good as zero in Mastodon. Most of my time on social media is me dwelling here.
I have an account but I don’t really use it. I don’t really know who I’d want to follow or what I’d want to post about. Same problem I had with (Pre-Musk) Twitter. I much prefer a platform like Lemmy, where I can subscribe to specific topics instead of people.
advice: you can follow hashtags
not just users
this may help
Okay but what would I even follow hashtag wise? I surely don’t want to follow ~500 #'s for politicians names or something. Sports teams I can review stats online, unless I was looking to following something like #bengalsinjuries or something, but who would know to tag that in a post letting me know if their linebacker didn’t tear his ACL but rather had a sprain?
Don’t the hashtags change quite often? I feel id end up with a slew of opinions about the war in Ukraine, and same with Iran, but nothing useful.
I think I just followed people who had garden stuff and chickens, same with loops, but neither have I really used enough to say I “use them”. Like it’s been 6 months since I signed into mastadon, and loops I signed into maybe a month ago to see how it was going.
i hope it works for you
but you can set keyword filters follow the big hashtags for example #politics #technology and many more
and then you can set it to show content warnings instead of hiding the entire thing (because it may hide normal stuff) so you can filter out useless stuff
I’ll give it a try sometime and see, who knows maybe I’ll change the way I invest content over time
lemmy communities are just users… so you can follow lemmy from mastodon
Which is cool, but it’s still not really what I’m looking for. Like if I follow a hashtag like #technology or whatever, I’ll just get a huge jumble of random opinions, repeating news articles etc. Whereas on something like Lemmy, it’s much more structured. Like when there’s some big news event, discussion will be concentrated on one post per community generally, and duplicates will be removed. I prefer having that kind of more orderly structure.
That is actually super nice.
and you have filters so you can automate displaying content warnings on useless stuff
I can only get so erect etc
I’ll say the same thing as everyone else, but with different emphasis:
If I cared about “microblogging”-style social media, which I don’t, Mastodon would be the service I would use.
I’ve been on Mastodon for 8 years and I currently use 3 different accounts on different instances. I do enjoy the format and following hashtags but admittedly, I don’t feel like I’ve made many friends there. Much like Lemmy, it’s been more about subjects than relationships.
I do wish I could figure out the secret recipe for that.
I do not, because I just don’t like the format. I never used Twitter either.
I grew up on vBulletin 5 forums and prefer longer thread-form content rather than short form Twitter style feeds. Reddit used to scratch that itch, now it’s Lemmy. Its just hard for my brain to navigate so I avoid it.















