Obviously know actual slavery was way way worse, as there was awful abuse, terrible living conditions, no freedom of expression or obtaining goods. BUT - If the premise of current society is that adults have to work until they have earned their freedom (earned enough money to retire) - that’s slavery. I don’t think people really internalise that for what it is.
You’re not allowed to go grow vegetables in a forest. You are forced to produce value for others because other people have claimed the land you need to sleep and grow food. They have no actual right to it. The people who first claimed it were probably not even the first people there, they were just the people violent enough to fight anyone that said it wasn’t theirs.
Yes. Of course. If a modest household cannot be in the black on one income its slavery.
Holy fuck lol
Sorry but no it isn’t, at least not in a marxist sense.
Written in the 1920s:
Yes, you are right: the law forbids theft.
If I should steal something from you, you can call a policeman and have me arrested. The law will punish the thief, and the government will return to you the stolen property, if possible, because the law forbids stealing. It says that no one has a right to take anything from you without your consent.
But your employer takes from you what you produce. The whole wealth produced by labor is taken by the capitalists and kept by them as their property.
The law says that your employer does not steal anything from you, because it is done with your consent. You have agreed to work for your boss for certain pay, he to have all that you produce. Because you consented to it, the law says that he does not steal anything from you.
But did you really consent?
When the highwayman holds his gun to your head, you turn your valuables over to him. You ‘consent’ all right, but you do so because you cannot help yourself, because you are compelled by his gun.
Are you not compelled to work for an employer? Your need compels you, just as the highwayman’s gun. You must live, and so must your wife and children. You can’t work for yourself; under the capitalist industrial system you must work for an employer. The factories, machinery, and tools belong to the employing class, so you must hire yourself out to that class in order to work and live. Whatever you work at, whoever your employer may be, it always comes to the same: you must work for him. You can’t help yourself. You are compelled.
In this way the whole working class is compelled to work for the capitalist class. In this manner the workers are compelled to give up all the wealth they produce. The employers keep that wealth as their profit, while the worker gets only a wage, just enough to live on, so he can go on producing more wealth for his employer. Is that not cheating, robbery?
The law says it is a ‘free agreement’. Just as well might the highwayman say that you ‘agreed’ to give up your valuables. The only difference is that the highwayman’s way is called stealing and robbery, and is forbidden by law. While the capitalist way is called business, industry, profit making, and is protected by law.
But whether it is done in the highwayman’s way or in the capitalist way, you know that you are robbed.
The whole capitalist system rests on such robbery.
The whole system of law and government upholds and justifies this robbery.
That’s the order of things called capitalism, and law and government are there to protect this order of things.
Do you wonder that the capitalist and employer, and all those who profit by this order of things, are strong for ‘law and order’?
But where do you come in? What benefit have you from that kind of ‘law and order’? Don’t you see that this ‘law and order’ only robs you, fools you, and just enslaves you?
‘Enslave me?’ you wonder. ‘Why, I am a free citizen!’
Are you free, really? Free to do what? To live as you please? To do what you please?
Let’s see. How do you live? What does your freedom amount to?
You depend on your employer for your wages or your salary, don’t you? And your wages determine your way of living, don’t they? The conditions of your life, even what you eat and drink, where you go and with whom you associate, — all of it depends on your wages.
No, you are not a free man. You are dependent on your employer and on your wages. You are really a wage slave.
The whole working class, under the capitalist system, is dependent on the capitalist class. The workers are wage slaves.
So, what becomes of your freedom? What can you do with it? Can you do more with it than your wages permit?
Can’t you see that your wage — your salary or income — is all the freedom that you have? Your freedom, your liberty, don’t go a step further than the wages you get.
The freedom that is given you on paper, that is written down in law books and constitutions, does not do you a bit of good. Such freedom only means that you have the right to do a certain thing. But it doesn’t mean that you can do it. To be able to do it, you must have the chance, the opportunity. You have a right to eat three fine meals a day, but if you haven’t the means, the opportunity to get those meals, then what good is that right to you?
So freedom really means opportunity to satisfy your needs and wants. If your freedom does not give you that opportunity, than it does you no good. Real freedom means opportunity and well-being. If it does not mean that, it means nothing.
You see, then, that the whole situation comes to this:
Capitalism robs you and makes a wage slave of you.
The law upholds and protects that robbery.
The government fools you into believing that you are independent and free.
In this way you are fooled and duped every day of your life.
But how does it happen that you didn’t think of it before? How is it that most other people don’t see it, either?
It is because you and every one else are lied to about this all the time, from your earliest childhood.
You are told to be honest, while you are being robbed all your life.
You are commanded to respect the law, while the law protects the capitalist who is robbing you.
You are taught that killing is wrong, while the government hangs and electrocutes people and slaughters them in war.
You are told to obey the law and government, though law and government stand for robbery and murder.
Thus all through life you are lied to, fooled, and deceived, so that it will be easier to make profits out of you, to exploit you.
Because it is not only the employer and the capitalist who make profits out of you. The government, the church, and the school — they all live on your labor. You support them all. That is why all of them teach you to be content with your lot and behave yourself.
‘Is it really true that I support them all?’ you ask in amazement.
Let us see. They eat and drink and are clothed, not to speak of the luxuries they enjoy. Do they make the things they use and consume, do they do the planting and sowing and building and so on?
‘But they pay for those things,’ your friend objects.
Yes, they pay. Suppose a fellow stole fifty dollars from you and then went and bought with it a suit of clothes for himself. Is that suit by right his? Didn’t he pay for it? Well, just so the people who don’t produce anything or do no useful work pay for things. Their money is the profits they or their parents before them squeezed out of you, out of the workers.
‘Then it is not my boss who supports me, but I him?’
Of course. He gives you a job; that is, permission to work in the factory or mill which was not built by him but by other workers like yourself. And for that permission you help to support him for the rest of your life or as long as you work for him. You support him so generously that he can afford a mansion in the city and a home in the country, even several of them, and servants to attend to his wants and those of his family, and for the entertainment of his friends, and for horse races and for boat races, and for a hundred other things. But it is not only to him that you are so generous. Out of your labor, by direct and indirect taxation, are supported the entire government, local, state, and national, the schools and the churches, and all the other institutions whose business it is to protect profits and keep you fooled. You and your fellow workers, labor as a whole, support them all. Do you wonder that they all tell you that everything is all right and that you should be good and keep quiet?
It is good for them that you should keep quiet, because they could not keep on duping and robbing you once you open your eyes and see what’s happening to you.
That’s why they are all strong for this capitalist system, for ‘law and order’.
But is that system good for you? Do you think it right and just? If not, then why do you put up with it? Why do you support it? ‘What can I do?’ you say; ‘I’m only one.’
Are you really only one? Are you not rather one out of many thousands, out of millions, all of them exploited and enslaved the same as you are? Only they don’t know it. If they knew it, they wouldn’t stand for it. That’s sure. So the thing is to make them know it.
Every workingman in your city, every toiler in your country, in every country, in the whole world, is exploited and enslaved the same as you are.
From Now And After by Alexander Berkman. Chapter 3: Law and Government.
Available to read or download in various formats, for free, here: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/alexander-berkman-what-is-communist-anarchism
I mean on the one hand, sure
On the other hand, slave-owners sort of had to actually make sure you had food, shelter, and healthy enough to sustain their workforce. Wal-mart don’t give a fuck if you have to sleep in your car and can’t make rent, show up in uniform and don’t complain or they will take the next desperate person and you risk being arrested for violating modern vagrancy laws.
People can interpret that how they will.
It’s almost like they’re offloading the cost of slave owning to the government.
You might even go further and say that capitalists in the 17th and early 18th century openly talked about how slavery was increasingly an inferior form of control. That with industrialization and urban concentration dragged down capital accumulation for capitalists and that in fact precarity of unemployment, starvation, loss of social status, and the ability to easily replace their workforce and offload the burdens you speak of was a cheaper and equally effective way to reproduce the same functional exploitation.
People can interpret that how they will.
This is not a matter of interpretation. Wall-Mart employees are citizens; legal humans with rights and access to the court system. Also there is the small difference that Wall-Mart doesn’t own it’s employee’s children and they’re not, in turn, required to work for Wall-Mart into perpetuity.
Sure, and further interpretation would be that the severing of any sort of responsibility for guaranteeing the material conditions of their workforce knowing that absent selling their labor, a individual risks precarity thus ensuring a steady pool of cheap, readily available labor, which increasingly became seen as a feature for capitalists, not a bug.
And that said court system, along with other tools of coercion and control within the state, were directly designed and structured by the ruling class to protect their class interests and sustain the necessary reproduction of exploitation for maintaining this system.
Slaves worked from before sunup to after sunrise subsisting on the human equivalent of dog food. Sleeping in any given car is a major step up from a wooden shack.
So the wealthiest nation in the history of humanity has managed to elevate the lowest of their citizenry from 12 hour work days eating dog food as slaves to living in cars to stock shelves full of goods produced in the periphery by slave labor that still works sun up to sun down and eats dog food….almost like all this labor being exploited is still overwhelmingly going to people who aren’t doing most of the labor.
It seems like most of your argument is against private land ownership moreso than wage slavery.
Fair point, but that part of the argument is referring to wage slavery as the only option left, as claiming land for a homestead is very rarely an option any longer.
“Chattel” slavery might be a helpful term
There’s no way this is an unpopular opinion on Lemmy.
It is an unpopular opinion in general, though
You can tell it’s popular because it has a good upvote ratio on the community for unpopular opinions.
Right? Go post this elsewhere. I’m here for spicy takes not to toe the lemmy line.
Spicy take: You’re fucking mental, “zoloftt”, and you don’t have the mental capacity to determine what anyone should or should not see.
“Nah, I named myself after my mental health drugs for no reason at all.”
“Toe” the line. You fucking brilliant spicy donut!
Jesus H Christ. I’m here to riff. Why are you so angry?
And thanks for the breakdown of my name Freud. Really unpacked a lot for me /s
Edit: ah, you’re a terminally online troll. I’ll remember to ignore you in the future
Grew cotton one time because I thought my toddler daughter would be fascinated. Carefully reached in to pull a boll loose and the dried, sharpened calxy slid under my skin 1/2". That took 3 weeks to stop hurting even with modern antibiotics and bandaids.
Go do that in the summer sun, bent over from before sunrise to after sunset, going as fast as you can, get your flesh removed if you fuck up. You’re only sustenance is the human equivalent of dog food and you sleep in a shack. BTW, I’m keeping your children. Go do all that then come back and tell me about slavery.
Perhaps we should ask someone who’s experienced both.
experience demonstrates that there may be a slavery of wages only a little less galling and crushing in its effects than chattel slavery, and that this slavery of wages must go down with the other.
— Frederick Douglass
Can’t two things be bad? Chattel slavery and wage slavery? Is this post not exploring this intersectionality?
Jobs suck but imo the crucial difference is that you can, in principle, move from job to job. That movement is what makes it not slavery.
That said, with reduced movement in the job market, a job looks more and more like slavery. Furthermore, the reduced ability of negotiating wages also means it looks more like slavery imo.
I feel that means you are enslaved to the system, not to the company. More like serfs than slaves
Uuuh I feel like thats moving away from the meaning of slave too much, albeit yes our dependence on a system effects freedom. Needs another word.
With serfs, again, since you can change which “lord” you work for so it isnt the same.
To be clear, this isnt negating the obvious freedom and human rights issues with a job.
Wage slave is good enough as a word for me
…obviously. that’s why they use the same words.
Wage slavery is a type of slavery, which is why it is called “slavery” with a descriptor in front of it.
A sledgehammer is a hammer.
As another person pointed out, “actual” slavery is better called chattel slavery.
sir, this is Unpopular Opinion
Right? I thought he was going to drop something that would piss me off. Jeez, thanks, captain obvious.
Flatearther, huh? I guess it would have to be really spicy compared to the spicy drop your sister takes on your face daily.
If you’re not speaking against slavery, you’re supporitng it. Pathetic.
Are you ok? You deduced that I’m a flatearther from my username and started throwing some sick comments like a moron? Are you serious? Are you really this stupid? What the fuck are you even talking about? Wow
“But people NEED to work or they’ll have nothing to do!” - everyone but us
While you still can’t plant vegetables in public space, in Sweden we have a “right of public access” that more or less enshrines foraging as a right
Lots of caveats to how far that can be taken, of course:
https://aresweden.com/en/about-are/the-swedish-right-of-public-access/
Once at my job, I had to help a customer after I clocked out. You can read all about it in my memoir: 12 minutes a Slave. 🙃
8 hours 12 minutes







