Today, I am wondering if Generative AI is one of the reasons that I started feeling aimless in my job as a researcher.

I work a lot with data in various forms and in the process of data analysis and preparation, I have started to rely quite a lot on the use of LLMs to do tasks for me that would otherwise be tedious and but represented a large share in what i was doing before. Last week, I was tasked to understand, structure, and organise a complex administrative data set with bad documentation, and unclear temporal coherency to make it available for analysis.

This would have been a challenging task some years ago. Maybe a week or two spent, focused on reading articles that have used the data set for other purposes, browsing documentation texts, looking up code bits on stackoverflow.

Instead, now, i bit by bit feed my instructions into an LLM trying to make sure it does the right things and provides the necessary documentation to keep the code sensible and human readable. But basically, I give a task, wait 20 minutes while the machine bobbles along, review what it had done, understand possible problems, set the next task, and then wait again.

In the in-between, I open a game of chess, or browse some articles (even interesting ones).

I can spend many hours like this, and usually finish the task quicker than i would have doing all the work by myself, or with an LLM of 3 years ago, where all code planning, and downloading was still done by hand, the LLM just helped me writing code blocks and syntax.

And I am wondering, if there is anything to do about this. Practically.

Because going back to the old world of doing 90 percent of the work (or even 100 percent), does not seem sensible from a pace perspective.

Yet, I also feel kind of empty while doing the task.

I am curious how other people have been in similar situation.

(I would like to propose to not make this a conversation about the ecological or ethical downsides of GenAI. They are real and relevant, yet, maybe this conversation can be more about the personal experience of LLM use)

  • DJKJuicy@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    16
    ·
    18 hours ago

    I dunno man. You’re describing the way I’ve felt for decades. You just added some new AI sprinkles.

    The question will always be can you adapt to the drudgery and be satisfied with this high paying but boring and unrewarding job, or will it eventually eat a hole in your soul that you can’t recover from?

  • Archimedes@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    34
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    21 hours ago

    The philosophical problem of what purpose we might have once liberated from toil is old af. It’s no secret that wealthy people are often unhappy, or decadent, or sociopathic, or whatever. I suspect that attaining such liberation is unhealthy for the individual within an evolutionary/cultural context of people defined by their toil. We don’t have any cultural legacy to lean on here because we always lived in cultures of toil, but probably (assuming material concerns are largely met by the Ai shift) we would need to rethink our cultural values - status is at the heart of it, it’s actually what motivates us. For now, status is derived primarily from wealth, but in a world of free time and abundance, the persuit of wealth becomes a shallow vanity. New cultural values are required. Perhaps expertise, social contribution, artistic contribution. Who knows?

    Im not hugely optimistic for our collective ability to choose that. I think rather they will emerge after a few generations of fighting over what scraps of toil remain.

    For you, as an individual, probably you are experiencing some sort of awakening to the absurdity of existence, a philosophical crisis. Are you around 40?😂 I propose engaging with the part of yourself that appreciates novelty, it’s fun and never a negative. But for the future it may be wise to consider who you are when you can no longer define a large part of yourself by the toil.

    These are strange times.

    • MrOtingocni@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      15 hours ago

      You’ve articulated what I had been trying to hammer on way better than I ever could. A decade ago I was asking people online “What is the value of a man who does not work?”

      I was trying to get people to think about the structure of society and the hierarchy of labor, the social mores, and how we can prepare for the future without it catching us with our pants down. I was, and am still, excited about the potential of the human race unshackled from the resource acquisition drive which has dominated our entire history. But it is also a powder keg if not handled with some forethought.

      And this didn’t require any particular prescience on my part; automation of labor was an increasingly frequent theme both in near sci-fi and real world.

      I never got anyone to engage in the topic with me about it. I thought it was extremely important to start putting our heads together about it now but… I guess it seemed too abstract or fantastical to really grab people. I also struggle to communicate clearly so that doesn’t help. I gave up after a while.

      Anyway, look at us now. LLMs might not be the AI it’s marketed to be but it’s already hitting society and the real thing will be here soon.

  • Colonel_Panic_@eviltoast.org
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    25
    ·
    21 hours ago

    Same. I have no idea if it is the AI or the slow, inevitable collapse of late stage Capitalism, or both… It’s probably both.

    For me it’s been about a year now where I truly do not enjoy my job anymore. I’ve been a programmer for over 2 decades and I’ve truly loved it all that time. The WFH Covid era was one of the absolute best, by far (not the death and sickness, the being remote and not having to do the whole song and dance). But then my job, like so many others, jerked us back into the office with the big RTO mandate. Even after we proved that remote work was FAR more productive and efficient and far happier employees. Nope, none of that mattered. What really matters is can a few executives walk around a building and feel important and get to watch their busy little bees working hard. That song and dance is what matters. And that’s when I stopped trying. That was what killed my spirit. It broke me. They don’t care about employees. They don’t care about efficiency or quality or anything. They want the song and dance routine. They just wanna LOOK busy and FEEL busy. And what’s the point anyway? If you ACTUALLY work hard and get things done you just get more work assignments. You don’t get a raise or a promotion or anything. They punish you for it. They WANT you to be inefficient and slow and do the song and dance.

    So I turned my brain off. I no longer really program or solve issues like I did before. I don’t make the company better. I go to all the meetings and I do my assignments at bare-minimum levels and move on. And it SUCKS. But it also vastly lowered my stress levels.

    Trying to do the performance of work, while also being actually productive is EXHAUSTING and STRESSFUL and MISERABLE!!!

    It’s AI, but also it’s really not. AI is one more big pile of crap on the already massive pile of crap that is work under capitalism.

    The only bit of advice I can toss out is from my therapy. “Don’t try to fight the current, learn to float.” Or whatever the saying is. Go with the flow. And if the river is flowing in a direction you truly do not want to go in, then get off the river and find another river.

    I am not truly happy with work this past year or so, I’m forced to go into an office to do work on a computer. It wastes half of my otherwise productive hours with commuting and moving around, but that’s what the company wants, not productivity, not problem solving, a dancing monkey, so I dance. The only reason I don’t quit is that it pays well, but it is no longer fulfilling.

    I really don’t think the issue is AI, it’s something bigger than that. It’s the entire concept of work and labor and jobs and productivity and life and all of it. I can’t really explain, but it isn’t JUST AI, that I know. The AI is more of a symptom, not the disease.

    • mad_lentil@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      15 hours ago

      I really don’t think the issue is AI, it’s something bigger than that. It’s the entire concept of work and labor and jobs and productivity and life and all of it. I can’t really explain, but it isn’t JUST AI, that I know. The AI is more of a symptom, not the disease.

      You put your finger on it there, friend. I wish it was just the AI that bothered me and I was just some luddite who didn’t like the new toy. But I’ve had a big issue with “tech work” for a long time, and ai has just brought all that into starker focus.

      Like I could cope before, but this fully nihilistic hyper-capitalism thing is just too much to ignore.

      Work sucks so much right now. I don’t believe in any of it and I feel bad for taking part in it.

    • baggachipz@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      19 hours ago

      I’m a vibe-coding meat proxy who manages other vibe-coding meat proxies. The job was never particularly important or interesting, but the pay is good and if I don’t try to derive meaning from my work I’m fine. The people I work with are mostly good and the health care is excellent (something I must have). After a long “career” chasing significance and social positivity, I’ve mostly decided to find meaning and stimulation elsewhere.

      These companies don’t care about us one bit and never have. RTO and unnecessary layoffs have proven that yet again. Specifically to the software industry, non-programmers have always resented the developer’s necessity. So now with this latest promise of “never needing developers again”, the mask slips back down until they have to put it on again after the inevitable collapse.

      • Colonel_Panic_@eviltoast.org
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        18 hours ago

        I call that band name!

        The Vibe Coding Meat Proxies!

        Yeah, for reals. I’ve leaned into all my hobbies and true joys more. I’ve stopped “giving 110%” (whatever that even means) and I am focusing on me and my family and close friends more.

        I never really felt much sense of purpose or pride in my career/work before, maybe some, I enjoyed and did pride myself in good work, but you do eventually realize just how expendable and worthless you are when a company lays off entire departments so easily. You can also build things your entire career somewhere that a manager can just decide to scrap all of it one day. It is all so fleeting. All jobs to a degree, but ESPECIALLY software.

        Companies all seem to want, as you so wonderfully put it, vibe coding meat proxies, so that’s what they can have. You and I both know that isn’t sustainable or going to end well for them, but they never listen to us, they look at charts and forecasts and what other companies are doing and they blindly copy it for fear of being left behind. So be it.

        But for now, the pay is good enough to stay. But as costs rise year after year that is quickly becoming less true.

        What comes next anyway?

        For all the generations before us it seemed simpler. Get a job, be good at it, buy house, have kids, retire.

        Now it’s, work hard, make just enough to not die, uhhhhhh. Now what?

  • mad_lentil@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    16 hours ago

    I wish I had the perspective of someone 5, 10, or 25 years from now. Because similarly to you, I can’t really feel “good” about using LLMs (although for me it’s as much about immediate satisfaction as it is those very real negative externalities that we all know by now).

    In the early clumsier years I thought GenAI was fun to play with, but as soon as it started showing up at work I hated it, because it very clearly came with a mandate. And then it’s like the better it got the less interested I was in using it, or even in doing a good job if this is the way things are going.

    I shouldn’t be surprised, but I felt betrayed by coworkers, bosses, and owners.

    Like that time I realised my employer was only letting me go hog on accessibility because it was a metric that a big client cared about. Everything is about the bottom line—not about making things better, easier, or more fun, and LLMs are just the latest technology to make it obvious (though not the first ofc).

    Increasingly I feel like any potentially cool technology works against us, at least at work.

  • Bonje@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    21 hours ago

    In the same boat.

    My job is mostly provisioning cloud infrastructure and reading pull requests. One is made trivial and the other my eyes glass over from the amount and number of changes.

    I offer no solace other than acknowledging that shit’s fucked.

  • dumples@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    13 hours ago

    Are we twins? You are almost perfectly describing me and my situation. I worked for multiple years as a research and development chemist and I loved the mix between hands on experiments and data analysis. It was all so interesting and mentally stimulating. As I “grew” it became clear I would have to do less and less mentally stimulating analysis and lab work and more boring project management and meetings. I hate that idea so I went to grad school for data science and had done that for almost a decade. It started super stimulating with lots to learn and problems and most importantly skills for me to learn. Now I feel like I know enough and LLM can do enough that there’s nothing new or mentally stimulating to do in my work days. I use LLM for most things I consider boring at my job (which is a lot these days) but keep the fun programming for myself. I’m like you where I am bored not as unstimulated but mentally unchallenged.

    I have been really trying recently to mentally stimulate myself during my workday by doing non work things. I do work from home so I do lots to keep the house going which are satisfying since I can see the task move from uncompleted to completed but the running of a house is pretty mentally unstimulating as well. I think I’m going to get into a new hobby I can while sitting at my computer (I’m thing macrame because I love knots and rope). I am also going to really try to read or do some herbalism during my workday without shame. But it’s a real challenge.

    You like me could try to change jobs or careers but I frankly the money, free time and benefits are too good.

  • notfromhere@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    18 hours ago

    I’m in project management, and the in between asks allows me to multitask and work on different things simultaneously, but that runs the risk of context switching and forgetting what I was doing, so I have to limit the number of simultaneous tasks, usually to about 3-4 open and active sessions. I’ll work on various things, documentation, skills repository, slides, user story board, etc. Then also running tickets, reviewing work, working with vendors, and more. AI has actually made my job fun again.

  • MagicShel@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    21 hours ago

    I can’t say whether AI affects you that way. I love being an answers guy and I love to tinker in pursuit of perfection I can never attain, and AI helps me find answers I wouldn’t have time to get on my own. I can run multiple production support investigations at once, and in my spare time I use AI to help me tune or add features to my tools. As a result, I get included in lots of investigations and I continually get positive reinforcement as I’m able to answer questions no one else can. If I wasn’t in that situation, I think I would find my job much less rewarding.

    My biggest problems tend to be organizational as I do whatever I’m working on in favor of the newest emergency. I try to use AI among other tools to help with that, but I’m 53 and I think it’s just not ever going to happen. Gives me something to tinker with, though.

  • Rhynoplaz@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    20 hours ago

    I’ve never used AI at work, and it still sucks, so I think the common denominator here is that work just sucks.

    • TrickDacy@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      19 hours ago

      I think ai has made it worse. There are other things affecting me too but what OP said resonates me. If I had been born 10 years earlier I could’ve probably done better in this career mental health wise. But right now I’m watching people go crazy with AI psychosis and I have no doubt my job will be obsolete soon. AI does a bad job at least half the time, but our society doesn’t exactly have high standards, especially when it comes to things perceived as faster or cheaper. I think it’s very likely my once-safe job will be eliminated within 5 years, and in the meantime I’m feeling less fulfilled all the time. Yes, work sucks, but losing the feeling that one is “useful” is another level of mindfuck.

  • opensesame_365@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    20 hours ago

    I feel like everyone comes to the conclusion that nothing we do or say has any real importance in life, AI is just a convenient scapegoat for many.

    Life is meaningless.

  • funkydutch@feddit.nl
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    20 hours ago

    Seems to be a common impression. Based on my experience: what about improving the tooling itself so you don’t need to guide as much? Then having it produce an artifact that the process worked? Like a report. Then what about comparing 3 way with other algos/approaches? Meanwhile what about setting up that new project or fixing a pet peeve? How about 3 tasks at the same time with 4D chess? Sounds snarky but that’s what I’ve been doing, plus a lot of free time to deal with personal things or readings. One more example: if it takes 10m can it take 5? LLM to the experiments. Is there a new research paper to apply to that data? LLM to find out