Well yes, but actually no. BG3 crit fail and DMG crit fail are different

You’re aware that barbs get resistance to bludgeoning, slashing and piercing irregardless of whether it’s magical, right? And that extends further with the bear totem

Crit fails like that are referenced as an optional rule in the DMG, minus the Nat 1 part

Yeah. Larian made some really good changes to D&D, then they added crit fails to skill checks