• Square Singer@feddit.de
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 years ago

    I totally disagree with Stallman’s views and personally I do find them pretty worrying.

    But I also disagree with the concept that employers should be the executive of the court of public opinion.

    We have real courts and real police, we don’t need to invent a secondary one where people lose their jobs due to shitstorms.

    If you think he did something illegal, report him to the police or sue him. If not, then this is freedom of speech. Even though he uses the freedom to voice a pretty crappy opinion.

    I mean, if everyone who said something that lots of people disagree with, I guess we would all be unemployed now.

    • MJBrune@beehaw.orgdeleted by creator
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      3 years ago

      I disagree. Things you say have consequences. The things you say actively reflect on your employer and future employers. You can try to deny it all you want but that’s the fact. I for one look poorly on the FSF for reinstating Stallman and I don’t think the FSF is a body of decision-makers that are capable of making the right choice. That’s kind of a major part of the FSF.

      • wsis@feddit.cl
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        3 years ago

        The things you say actively reflect on your employer and future employers.

        why?

        Imagine a interview where employer tries to know every aspect of your personality and ideas, before hiring you.

        Seems quite impossible.

        For a celebrity like Stallman seems easy. But imagine checking the background of a random candidate just to see if she posted something bad years ago. And rejecting her application because of a post defendig the wrong ideas.

        I agree we already have courts and police. If he did something illegal, there’s a course of action there.

        • davehtaylor@beehaw.org
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          3 years ago

          For a random, non-public-facing employee, sure. But Stallman is the founder, and has always been the face and the voice of the FSF. He’s their mascot, their evangelist. He’s the one people see and think of when they think of the FSF. If he’s out here spouting extremely problematic views, and the FSF continues to employ him, then it looks like the organization as a whole is supporting those views.

          • Square Singer@feddit.de
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            3 years ago

            I’m pretty sure that most people are mature enough to differentiate between an organization that makes software and nothing at all to do with kids and/or sexuality and that old wierdo’s personal views.

            We live in a world where huge corporations with a revenue higher than the GDP of many countries routinely exploit child labour and work their workers to death or suicide, burning whole countries and pushing climate change while at it. And yet we collectively shrug and still buy Nestle, Apple, Samsung or H&M.

            A shitstorm towards such a niche and unknown organisation as the FSF really doesn’t matter. We all know the Stallman and the FSF, because we are into computers, software and/or open source. But ask any random person on the street, thew wouldn’t know who Stallman or the FSF is if you told them that it’s not Android but actually Chrome/Android SDK/Dalvik/Toybox/Linux that runs on their phone.

            • davehtaylor@beehaw.org
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              3 years ago

              I’m pretty sure that most people are mature enough to differentiate between an organization that makes software and nothing at all to do with kids and/or sexuality and that old wierdo’s personal views.

              That’s not how PR works.

              We live in a world where huge corporations with a revenue higher than the GDP of many countries routinely exploit child labour and work their workers to death or suicide, burning whole countries and pushing climate change while at it. And yet we collectively shrug and still buy Nestle, Apple, Samsung or H&M.

              This is just whataboutism.

              A shitstorm towards such a niche and unknown organisation as the FSF really doesn’t matter. We all know the Stallman and the FSF, because we are into computers, software and/or open source. But ask any random person on the street, thew wouldn’t know who Stallman or the FSF is if you told them that it’s not Android but actually Chrome/Android SDK/Dalvik/Toybox/Linux that runs on their phone.

              So just because the FSF is a niche org, we should just ignore the problematic public statements by it’s founder and the person who’s always been at the forefront of their PR?

              Tbh, this just sounds like free speech absolutism apologia. Yes, people can say whatever they want. But they are not free from consequences. I want nothing to do with an org that would have Stallman as a part of it. I don’t want to be associated with anyone who would. If you continue supporting an org that supports someone like Stallman, then both you and the org approve of the things he’s saying. Period. Your words mean nothing. Your actions speak for themselves.

              • Square Singer@feddit.de
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                3 years ago

                Your actions do nothing. You complain on the internet about some guy that said something you don’t like. Nobody from FSF is gonna read it. And neither will Stallman or anyone that matters.

                I don’t see you boycotting software related to FSF. And even if you do, it doesn’t even matter, since the overwhelming majority of FOSS users never donate any money at all.

                You are no customer of the FSF, you just enjoy their stuff for free.

                So your actions amount to angry screaming into a box.

    • spookedbyroaches@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      3 years ago

      What do you mean?

      He said that Stallman had some fucked up views, showed quotes on what his views are, explained how this is a pattern, and finally said why this should make it so that we reject him in the Free Software community.

      Which part was the non sequitur?

      • rah@feddit.uk
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        3 years ago

        He made conclusions from quotes which didn’t follow from contents of those quotes.

          • rah@feddit.uk
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            edit-2
            3 years ago

            About this quote:

            'Senate candidate Roy Moore tried to start dating/sexual relationships with teenagers some decades ago.

            He tried to lead Ms Corfman step by step into sex, but he always respected “no” from her and his other dates. Thus, Moore does not deserve the exaggerated condemnation that he is receiving for this. As an example of exaggeration: one mailing referred to these teenagers as “children”, even the one that was 18 years old. Many teenagers are minors, but none of them are children.

            The condemnation is surely sparked by the political motive of wanting to defeat Moore in the coming election, but it draws fuel from ageism and the fashion for overprotectiveness of “children”.’

            DeVault says that Stallman draws a distinction between children and teenagers

            ‘especially to suggest that an adult having sex with a minor is socially acceptable’

            but Stallman makes no such suggestion. In fact, Stallman makes no mention of social acceptability at all. DeVault is putting words in Stallman’s mouth.

            About this quote:

            'Calling teenagers “children” encourages treating teenagers as children, a harmful practice which retards their development into capable adults.

            In this case, the effect of that mislabeling is to smear Wilson. It is rare, and considered perverse, for adults to be physically attracted to children. However, it is normal for adults to be physically attracted to adolescents. Since the claims about Wilson is the latter, it is wrong to present it as the former.’

            DeVault says that Stallman

            ‘sought to normalize adult attraction to minors, literally describing it as “normal”’

            but Stallman did not say that adult attraction to “minors” is normal.

            Acknowledgement of correctness please.

            • spookedbyroaches@lemm.ee
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              3 years ago

              You’re right, DeVault probably made a leap in accusing Stallman of describing sex with teenagers socially acceptable. But I can see where he comes from since Stallman is very insistent on the delineation of children and teenagers especially when child sexual abuse cases are in the news.

              On the second point, I think he did say that attraction to minors is normal. He defined adolescents as minors before and he’s saying attraction to them is normal here.

              • rah@feddit.uk
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                edit-2
                3 years ago

                On the second point, I think he did say that attraction to minors is normal. He defined adolescents as minors before and he’s saying attraction to them is normal here.

                He said attraction to adolescents is normal. He did not say that attraction to minors is normal. Distinguishing between the two is his whole point.

                Instead of paying attention to what Stallman is actually saying, DeVault chose to disregard Stallman’s word, “adolescent” and instead claim that he used a different word, “minor”, a more general word which includes a larger group, children. DeVault is clearly trying to paint Stallman as something he is not. Which, ironically, is exactly what Stallman was criticising the media for in his quote. And bizarrely, even though I’ve pointed this out to you, you’re doing the same.

                He defined adolescents as minors before and he’s saying attraction to them is normal here.

                “Adolescents are animals. Adult attraction to adolescents is normal. Therefore adult attraction to animals is normal.”

                “Adolescents are animals. Adult attraction to adolescents is normal. A person who says that adult attraction to adolescents is normal is saying that adult attraction to animals is normal.”

                These are non sequiturs, just like yours and DeVault’s assertions. Please try to think.

                https://press.rebus.community/intro-to-phil-logic/chapter/chapter-1/

                • spookedbyroaches@lemm.ee
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  0
                  ·
                  3 years ago

                  Stallman said

                  As an example of exaggeration: one mailing referred to these teenagers as “children”, even the one that was 18 years old. Many teenagers are minors, but none of them are children.

                  So I believe that he thinks that a “minor” is someone who is below the age of 18. “Many teenagers are minors” meaning not all of them since 18 and 19 year-olds are not minors but the rest are. I think this is a good-faith interpretation of what Stallman means. Stallman also said

                  In this case, the effect of that mislabeling is to smear Wilson. It is rare, and considered perverse, for adults to be physically attracted to children. However, it is normal for adults to be physically attracted to adolescents. Since the claims about Wilson is the latter, it is wrong to present it as the former.’

                  Thus, he most likely means that the adolescents he was referring to are minors. Unless he counts 18-25 year-olds as adolescents which is very unlikely in my opinion. Unless something is wrong here with my interpretation, DeVault asserting that Stallman thinks being attracted to minors is normal is a totally reasonable thing to say.

  • X3I@lemmy.x3i.tech
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    3 years ago

    I say this time and time again; only listen to people regarding their field of authority. For anything outside the world of software, Stallman’s opinions should not be seen any more valid or important than any other person on the internet. We should stick to that more. (What happened/happens due to his position in the FSF is a different topic)

    • flatbield@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      3 years ago

      People do the same with Musk. What anyone cares what Stallman, or Musk, says about things they know nothing about is beyond me.They both have said crazy things.

      • b0rlax@beehaw.org
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        3 years ago

        Except Musk is a disgustingly rich egomaniac who is using his money to influence the world based on shit opinions and beliefs. Stallman is just some creepy software dork that seems to keep to himself with his shitty opinions and beliefs.

        Pretty bad comparison tbh.